mostly but also it comes down to the writing more than the art.
When marvel tried the recent venom switch up and put some edgy Not-sasuke as their MC, the art was attacked as well. But venom, especially broken and weak, having a battle of wills with someone should look edgy with heavy inks and all that. The writing was the problem. "Derrr I've trained to lock myself in a black room and not be sad and be able to mentally dismantle all living things because muh special forces".
Basically what I'm saying is, it's usually the writing and not the art. It also comes down to interests. Some people legitimately enjoy cringy "le I'm so evil" shit so no matter how edgy it is they'll like it. I don't like that stuff and I'd call it edgy and cringe but, for instance, some people really enjoy new 52 batman.