>>219675907She wasn't a retard though, her reasoning to save madoka based on the original madoka's desire was incorrect as it didn't take into account the current madoka's feelings that had been shaped by her being a magical girl, but even if you disregard that the bigger problem is that QB was able to confirm the existence of the LoC and he said it himself if he can interfere with it, then he can control it at which point Homura flips her shit realzing that QB intends to do just that. If Homura had left with Madoka, QB would eventually learn to control madokami and be able to ensalve her, there's no way Homura could allow that, her only other choice was the actions she took and the first thing she does after is fuck QB's shit up.