I have a theory about why we are all pissed about Homura's actions in Madoka:Rebellion.

We feel cucked.

This seems like an outrageous theory at first, but then look at it from a basement dweller's point of view.

I am a INTJ in the MBTI system. This means I am a nasty basement-dweller vile son of a bitch who plots and schemes on how my vision of a better world could better be achieved; I because I am introverted; N because I am intuitive (can detect patterns); T because I shut down my feelings in thinking of how to create an ideal world; and J because I am a judgemental scumbag. But at heart, I am am idealistic, which is why Madoka represents to me, someone worthy of my awe and admiration.

Madoka as a character is INFP. She's shy (I), learns from past experience (N), but feels (F) and perceives (P) instead of judge.

And the reason why I am so angry is because Homura took that beautiful manifestation of idealism away from as many people as possible and made it herself. I'm not saying that it's wrong.

But I feel cucked.

It's like a thirsty man going to an oasis and drinking all of the water. Homura has her reasons.

But as a person who has seen my ideals violated and shattered repeatedly in front of my eyes, yet still holding onto them with all of my hatred and anger - to see an INFP get taken away by someone else

It's a special type of absolute humiliation.

What is your MBTI? How have you been drawn to Madoka's saintly personality? What are your ideals and how do they relate to Madoka?

TL;DR The concept of Madoka comforted me and gave inspiration to keep holding onto my ideals and Homura cucked me.